Security guarantees, money, or Donbas: Expert explains what the US and Russia are currently arguing about

Donald Trump, Putin

Political scientist Ruslan Bortnyk explained that the balance of the war remains the same as it was in 2023: Russia cannot win, but it also cannot yet negotiate a peaceful settlement with the US, reports Politeka.
He shared these thoughts in his blog.

"The parties have failed to draft a one-page document, they couldn’t even sign something on a napkin. This is because the complex issues of security guarantees and Ukraine's sphere of influence remain unresolved. And they also can’t agree on the money, ranging from Russia’s frozen assets to the lifting of sanctions. These two issues — security guarantees and money — are what is on the table today. It’s not about Donetsk region; it’s about which sphere of influence Ukraine will fall into and how much each side will pay for what has happened. These two issues are unresolved," says Ruslan Bortnyk.

According to the expert, in this context, meetings between leaders should end with a signed document, otherwise, it means there is no agreement. Otherwise, verbal agreements can be rewritten at will. Signed documents, he emphasizes, are necessary even in everyday life, let alone in discussions between the US and Russia, who, by the way, are under immense internal pressure from hawks and external pressure from Europe, Ukraine, and China, respectively.

"The main reason is that the balance of the war will likely remain roughly the same as it was in 2023, with Ukraine’s counteroffensive. Russia continues to advance and capture territory but cannot achieve a strategic advantage in the war. Accordingly, Ukraine says that, since you’re not winning strategically, the war could last 10 years, and in that time Putin will die, Russia will collapse, and its economy will collapse, so there’s no point in making deep concessions to Moscow,” explains Ruslan Bortnyk.

Therefore, he concludes, until the strategic balance on the front changes, along with internal societal stability and support for the government, reaching mutual concessions will be very difficult, if not impossible.



Latest news:

Let's remember Politeka wrote, Expert Explains Why Europe Is Providing Ukraine with War Aid: “It’s the Greatest Shield”

Politeka also informed, He became one of the brightest figures in Polish politics: Sławomir Majman talks about the new president of Poland

In addition, Politeka informed, Expert Explains Whether the West Can Destroy Russia’s Shadow Fleet


“We’re not even at the halfway point yet”: expert assesses how long the peace talks may drag on

Buffer, frontier, or leader: an expert explains Ukraine’s geopolitical position

“Under the Cover of Night at Witkoff’s Club”: An Expert Explains Why Talks in Miami Are Needed Again

“Washington Has Given the Green Light”: Expert Assesses What Mission the Coalition of the Willing Is Preparing in Ukraine

Congress Elections: Expert Assesses Whether Trump’s Position on Ukraine Will Change if Democrats Win

“The last and decisive battle”: expert assesses who will win the fight over the peace plan

Renouncing NATO in exchange for guarantees: an expert explained how to avoid a new Budapest Memorandum

Parallel Worlds: Expert Explains Why It’s Too Early to Pay Attention to Various Peace Plans

Lack of geopolitical status: expert assesses what pushed Putin to wage war against Ukraine

The window of opportunity will not open before February: expert explains why there will be no progress in negotiations in the near future

New U.S. National Security Strategy: Expert Explains Why Trump Wants to Get Closer to Russia

Security Guarantees from the U.S. and an 800,000-Strong Ukrainian Army: Expert Speaks About Progress in Negotiations

The Concept of Limited Sovereignty: Expert Explains Why Trump and Putin Think Alike

We won’t have elections like in Russia: expert assesses whether the U.S. can guarantee Ukraine’s security to hold elections

“The United States Wants to Pull Russia Away from China”: Expert Explains Trump’s Economic Plans

Expert explains why Trump started talking about elections in Ukraine: an additional element of pressure

“They’re looking for complicated solutions to simple issues”: expert explains how the U.S. is trying to bring Ukraine’s and Russia’s positions closer

A New Stage: Expert Reveals What the Talks in London Were About

Europe Against Trump: Expert Assesses Whether Partners Will Save Ukraine From Concessions to Russia

Show more